I wanted to interview Malcolm Guite before interviewing Malcolm Guite was cool.
Nearly a year ago he was visiting Nashville and I was trying to get the Cambridge poet, priest, chaplain, and literary storyteller into studio at CCM Magazine. Some of my friends weren’t entirely convinced. “Logan, you talk to pop stars, actors, hip hop artists. What are we doing here?” Unfortunately, scheduling got in the way. Fast-forward several months, and those same people were suddenly asking if I’d heard of Malcolm Guite.
Yes. Yes, I had.

Somewhere along the way, a British poet with a pipe, a beard that defies time, and a passion for Arthurian legend had become an unlikely internet sensation. And perhaps the most surprising part wasn’t his popularity, but who was watching.
Guite told me that when he finally discovered the analytics behind his YouTube channel, he found that approximately 80% of his now quarter-of-a-million subscribers were young men between 18 and 30. In a world dominated by quick clips, disposable entertainment, and increasingly artificial content, young men were voluntarily spending their time listening to an old wizardly gentleman recite poetry and discuss C.S. Lewis. Maybe we shouldn’t be so surprised.
“I had a hunch that we needed this,” Guite explained, describing a modern world he sees as increasingly flattened and accelerated. For Guite, the solution isn’t necessarily abandoning technology. It’s rediscovering humanity. And that mission is at the heart of his ambitious new literary project, Merlin’s Isle: An Arthurian. Guite’s latest book in the series, The Coming of Arthur, is the second installment in his four-volume epic, published by Nashville-based Rabbit Room Press.
The 372-page poetic retelling of this well-known tale follows the remarkable success of Galahad and the Grail, which reached Amazon’s Top 50 bestselling books and has sold tens of thousands of copies. For Guite, this isn’t simply an exercise in literary nostalgia. It’s an effort to recover the Christian foundations he believes have been obscured in modern retellings.
“I also wanted to restore the heart of the Christian mystery in the stories,” he told me. He also sees Arthur’s coming-of-age journey as particularly relevant to young people today. “This is a coming of age story,” Guite explained, describing Arthur as a young man learning to accept his destiny, “but also learn that leadership is service.”
The series is being written in traditional ballad form, a deliberate choice that gives the poetry a musical quality. And perhaps in the ultimate rejection of our automated age, Guite writes the epic longhand with a fountain pen. He recalled his delight when The Times of London reviewed the first volume and described it as “the exact opposite of AI slop.”
While his retelling is being largely accepted, there is another adaptation coming that has been met with internet controversy. Of course, I am speaking of Greta Gerwig’s upcoming Narnia: The Magician’s Nephew for Netflix.
I admit it. I loved the trailer. Watching my children, who adore Lewis’s books, realize they were seeing Narnia brought me genuine joy. And hearing Led Zeppelin’s famously difficult-to-license “Stairway to Heaven” accompanying the imagery of Aslan was an emotional experience.
But I wanted to know what Guite thought, especially with him being a scholar of Lewis while also crafting his own reinterpretation of beloved literature. His answer was fascinating.
“I’m slightly, taken aback by the way, a lot of Christians… have rushed to judgment on the basis of a few minutes of trailer,” he told me. Guite revealed that he had actually spoken with Greta Gerwig as she was beginning to develop her vision for Narnia. His advice to the filmmaker?
“Trust the story. The story knows more than either of us do. Let the story be the story.”
Guite also offered a personal defense of Gerwig’s intentions, based on his conversations with her.
“She loves Lewis and she loves these stories,” he said. His perspective on why Narnia matters goes considerably deeper than cinematic fidelity. Reflecting on his own spiritual journey, Guite said of Lewis: “He opened a wardrobe door into the kingdom of God.”
It’s a remarkable discussion about art, faith, and the freedom to revisit beloved stories without forgetting why they mattered in the first place. Of course, I couldn’t let Malcolm leave without getting into music.
When you have 30 minutes, I encourage you to pull up YouTube and enjoy our full CCM Magazine discussion. Get warm and cozy. Settle in for tales of King Arthur, C.S. Lewis, Jerry Garcia, and the future of Christianity in Britain. This conversation went places few CCM interviews have gone before.
But perhaps the most compelling thread was Guite’s hope that these ancient stories might awaken something spiritually profound in a new generation.
The Coming of Arthur is available now from Rabbit Room Press. The four-volume Merlin’s Isle series continues with Days of the Round Table in 2027 and concludes with The Passing of Arthur in 2028. The companion documentary, Merlin’s Isle: The Tale This Land Still Keeps, is also available to watch online.
For more information and to order the books, visit Rabbit Room Press or Merlin’s Isle.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.